Russian gas crisis puts a flame under nuclear debate in Europe
Brussels (AFP) Jan 11, 2009 Cuts in Russian gas supplies to Europe via Ukraine have reignited interest in Europe about using nuclear energy as an alternative to hydrocarbons, sparking environmentalists' ire. "On nuclear energy, this crisis will have consequences for the way we consider energy security in all EU countries," said Czech Energy Minister Martin Riman, whose country holds the bloc's rotating presidency. "One of the ways this might happen is to argue in favour of the return of nuclear energy," he told a news conference in Brussels on Thursday. The debate is already going strong in former Soviet bloc members of the European Union which are highly dependent on Russian gas and have been hit hard by supply cuts in the standoff between Moscow and Kiev. Even as Russia and Ukraine neared a deal that would lead to a resumption of gas supplies, Slovakia said Saturday it would begin reopening a power generator at the Jaslovske Bohunice nuclear plant because of the cutoff. The decision was taken "in the interests of Slovakia, industry and citizens" Prime Minister Robert Fico said. On December 31, Slovakia shut down the last unit of the Jaslovske Bohunice plant in line with a commitment it made as a condition for its 2004 entry into the EU. "We know that this is a violation of our conditions of membership" in the European Union, he said, but given the circumstances, there is "a risk of a blackout" that must be addressed. European Commission chief Jose Manuel Barroso had warned Slovakia against the move, saying that the response to the gas cuts was not to go back on promises. Nuclear energy has long been one of the most sensitive subjects in Europe and it got a boost last year during the oil price boom when it was seen in some countries such as Britain and Italy as a possible alternative. However, other countries slowly giving up on nuclear energy, such as Belgium, Germany and Sweden, refuse that it be openly touted as a solution for Europe's future energy needs. Meanwhile other European countries such as Ireland and Spain have never used nuclear energy. France, by far Europe's biggest nuclear power generator, has promoted its use as a way of reducing greenhouse gases blamed for global warming. Paris sees the Russian gas crisis as another argument in favour of nuclear energy, not to mention a source for potential new contracts for state controlled power giant Electricite de France. Currently, nuclear energy generates about one third of the EU's electricity and accounts for about 15 percent of the bloc's total energy consumption. However, nuclear energy varies by country from accounting for none at all to being the source of 80 percent of France's energy. But with the EU's dependence on energy imports on the rise, the cut in Russian supplies shows that "nuclear energy should be developed because it is a major guaranteed source in Europe's energy mix," a senior French diplomat said. However, environmentalists say that increased nuclear energy use is not as good an idea as it may seem. "Nuclear energy is used to generate electricity while 90 percent of Russian gas imports to Europe are used for heating. They're two different things," said Greenpeace official Jan Beranek. Also environmentalists point out that while nuclear power may not contribute to greenhouse gas emissions, the long-term problem of disposing of nuclear waste remains a major challenge. "Moreover, countries such as Bulgaria, Slovakia and the Czech Republic depend on Russian fuel for their nuclear plants which means that the issue of dependence on Russia is not solved. "These countries would do better to improve their energy efficiency," he said.
earlier related report The decision was taken "in the interests of Slovakia, industry and citizens" Prime Minister Robert Fico said. On December 31, Slovakia shut down the last unit of the plant, meeting a commitment it made to the European Union that paved the way for its 2004 entry into the bloc. "We know that this is a violation of our conditions of membership" in the European Union, he said, but given the circumstances, there is "a risk of a blackout" that must be addressed. Fico had said previously that the Soviet-designed VI nuclear block might be reopened to offset the impact of the global financial crisis. Slovakia has always argued that the plant is safe and could have continued to operate until 2020 or 2025. On Wednesday, the biggest Slovak gas company SPP curbed deliveries for industrial clients after Russia cut off all gas deliveries to Slovakia. The Russia-Ukraine dispute has led to cuts in gas for heating in Europe amid a cold snap. The crisis was sparked on New Year's Day when Russia cut gas supply to Ukraine hours after the two ex-Soviet countries failed to come to terms on Kiev's payment of arrears and a purchase price for 2009. After that cut, volumes of Russian gas transiting Ukraine to clients in Europe began to drop dramatically. Moscow accused Kiev of illegally siphoning gas while Ukraine countered that Russia was intentionally manipulating supply. Several days later, Russia charged that Ukraine had completely shut down all pipelines transporting Russian gas to Europe. Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin then ordered the halting of gas being pumped to Europe through Ukraine, sparking sudden cuts downstream. Share This Article With Planet Earth
Related Links Powering The World in the 21st Century at Energy-Daily.com
Analysis: Chevron Nigeria resumes oil flow Washington DC (UPI) Jan 07, 2009 Chevron has lifted its extended force majeure on oil exports from Nigeria caused by attacks by militants on its installations in the Niger Delta. |
|
The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement |